Special Paper No.11


Discount Control Mechanisms

Keeping Control

The discount is voluntary

Robin Angus, Director of Personal Assets Trust 1984-2020

With the recent publication of A Shared Journey, an Anthology of Personal Assets Trust Quarterly Reports, this seems like an appropriate moment to revisit one, and arguably the greatest, of the many contributions made by Robin Angus to the Trust and wider investment company sector: the ‘Discount Control Mechanism’ (‘DCM’).

Troy and the Board of Personal Assets Trust (‘PAT’) receive several letters and emails each year asking why we maintain the DCM. We recently even received the suggestion that we should stop issuing new shares in PAT and allow the Trust to trade on an expanding premium, thereby allowing existing shareholders to exit at an inflated price! Those who study Robin’s writings will know that, whilst such a decision might well provide a temporary uplift in the share price, the long term, and investing on behalf of the long-term shareholder, has always been PAT’s priority. Thanks to the DCM, PAT’s share price will move up and down in line with its net asset value (‘NAV’) – no more and no less – over the long run.

The aim of this Special Paper is to explain the merits of the DCM for investment trusts, and why it is particularly appropriate for PAT. After a year where investment companies’ collective discounts to NAV have widened sharply (see Figure 1) DCMs are as relevant as ever.

Discount Freedom Day

First, some ancient history. PAT introduced its DCM in November 1999, following the changes made to the Companies Act which allowed investment companies to buy back shares more tax efficiently. Before then, companies had been permitted to buy back shares for cancellation only by using revenue reserves, which were ordinarily utilised for smoothing dividend income. Directors were therefore understandably reluctant to use revenue reserves for buybacks. When the law changed on ‘Discount Freedom Day’, as Robin called it, an investment company was permitted to distribute realised capital profits by way of a redemption or purchase of its own shares. Companies could hold shares in Treasury and then subsequently reissue them. This, as Robin described it at the time, was “the best thing to happen to the trust sector since 1979 and 1980, when exchange controls were abandoned and capital gains tax within trusts’ portfolios was abolished in the first year of Mrs Thatcher’s rule.”

This change not only permitted trusts to buy back shares at discounts, thereby enhancing their NAV; it also made it possible to abolish the discount altogether, ensuring that a trust’s share price traded consistently close to its net asset value per share. Yet today, many trust boards overseeing liquid portfolios remain prisoners of their own discount and believe they can do little about it.

The DCM, in Practice

Since 1999, the Board of PAT had been responsible for setting the specific parameters under which the DCM operates. These include the level of discount and premium at which the shares are either bought back or issued. In June 2008, the Board went a step further, enshrining the DCM into the Company’s Articles of Association with a view to “outlawing the discount”. The DCM, now established, can only be reversed at the behest of our shareholders.

There was at that time, and remains, a long history of investment trust directors failing to meet promises to reduce their discount. Some trusts seem happy to issue shares when they trade on a premium but are more reluctant to buy them back when they trade below NAV. When markets become difficult, performance wanes or an investment mandate becomes less fashionable, it is easy to renege on prior commitments to shareholders. The market, however, is unforgiving. Broken pledges of this nature tend to undermine credibility, which in turn can lead to further steepening of the discount.

But I Love a Discount!

Many years ago, not long after Troy had been appointed as Investment Adviser to PAT, I met a private investor who said he liked investing in investments trusts. He also appreciated PAT’s capital preservation mandate but could not bring himself to pay a modest premium for the shares. I explained how the DCM worked, and he was disappointed, saying that he would wait for the shares to trade on a discount. I suggested that he might be waiting a while!

There is a small yet loud minority for whom the discount is a pre-requisite for investment. These are the traders, speculators and arbitrageurs who, by definition, tend not to be long-term investors. Rather, they are brokers thriving on portfolio activity, or arbitrageurs buying with a view to selling as soon as the discount has closed. They are often short-term and not interested in the Trust’s underlying investments. Most importantly, their aims and aspirations are not aligned with those of long-term shareholders. Trusts with DCMs, like PAT, tend not to attract this part of the market because there is no discount to play with.

Corporate financiers rarely advocate for a DCM. Their job, as it was once explained to me, is to ‘hatch, match and dispatch’ investment trusts or, in other words, to facilitate the IPOs, mergers and winding-up of trusts. The more activity the better. The same corporate broker said to me that PAT was ‘just weird’, and that the DCM would not work for other trusts. Perhaps this was because it was not in his interest. After twenty years, the evidence is there for all to see and I am pleased to say that a select few other investment trusts have followed, introducing their own DCMs with success.

A premium is just as bad. Excess demand pushes shares to a premium, in the same way that excess supply leads to shares trading on a discount. The outcome is exaggerated price movements in both directions, leading to undesirable volatility. As Robin reminds us, “Making up a loss of value caused by a change in rating from a 10% premium to a 10% discount is very hard indeed.” Our experience shows that a high premium, however desirable, is rarely sustained.

Shrink to Grow

PAT’s DCM has been tried and tested, through the market turmoil of 9/11 in 2001, the Global Financial Crisis of 2008/9 and the pandemic in 2020. Despite these tests and more, PAT has not sold at a meaningful discount since 1999 (see Figure 2). Over this time, the Trust has grown from £68m to £1.9bn. This has benefitted shareholders by lowering the Trust’s ongoing charge ratio from c. 1.2% when Troy was appointed Investment Adviser in 2009, to 0.67% today (see Figure 3). Buying shares at a modest discount and issuing at a small premium also enhances the Trust’s NAV. This has provided over £17m of benefit to shareholders since 20091. Yet, in order to grow, we must be prepared to shrink.

Most importantly, minimising the discount enables shareholders to sell their shares when they need to at close to net asset value. Such sale decisions can often occur at moments of market stress, which is usually when discounts are at their widest. Boards need to recognise the changing nature of an investment trust’s shareholder base, which is increasingly comprised of private investors. Directors, in our view, have a responsibility to provide shareholders an exit at a time of their choice, without suffering the penalty of a discount.

Equally important when thinking about facilitating the transactions of new and existing shareholders, DCMs help in improving investment trust liquidity. There are days and weeks when stock market liquidity dries up, as it did during the pandemic and during the mini-budget saga of last autumn. It is at times like these that Steven Budge and his team at Juniper Partners, who are responsible for the administration of the DCMs for all of Troy’s trusts, can step into the market to buy shares (see Figure 4). Our analysis shows that PAT, Troy Income & Growth Trust (‘TIGT’) and Securities Trust of Scotland (‘STS’) are more liquid than their respective peers of comparable size. This may be more important to some shareholders than others, but there is value in knowing that the exit exists.

It’s Not for Everyone

Of course, while a DCM may be appropriate for trusts invested in equities, fixed income and other liquid asset classes, it would not be suitable for those investing in illiquid assets such as private equity, smaller companies, alternatives such as renewables, music royalties and, the ultimate illiquid asset, property. And trusts of this type make up a greater proportion of the sector today.

Those using gearing aggressively may also have less flexibility to use buybacks. A falling market inherently increases gearing by reducing the value of the assets relative to fixed amount of debt; buybacks would exacerbate the problem. PAT has no structural gearing, and both TIGT and STS deploy sensibly low levels of gearing, via flexible bank lending. We have witnessed several incidents over the years of trusts being forced to suspend buybacks or reverse leverage at times of market stress. This may compound the matter.

Troy Trusts and DCMs

At Troy, we seek to be outward-looking. We are keen to advocate the benefits of DCMs to other fund management companies that manage investment trusts. I am always happy to meet managers of trusts to discuss the benefits of introducing a DCM.

Similarly, the PAT Board would be delighted to engage with other trust boards on the subject.

We believe this is all part of putting shareholders first.

Figure 1 – Investment company discounts widened in 2022

Past performance is not a guide to future performance. Source: Numis Securities, January 2023

Figure 2 – PAT Discount to net asset value

Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

Since sector established in 2010 Source: Refinitiv Datastream, 28 February 2023

Figure 3 – PAT ongoing charges ratio (‘OCR’) has fallen over time

Source: PAT Report & Accounts, 30 April 2022

Figure 4 – PAT shares in issue [RHS] – issuance & buybacks [LHS]#

Adjusted for Stock Split in 2022 Source: Juniper Partners, 31 January 2023

1Juniper Partners

All information in this document is correct as at 9 March 2023. Please refer to Troy’s Glossary of Investment terms here. Performance data provided relating to the NAV is calculated net of fees with income reinvested unless stated otherwise. Overseas investments may be affected by movements in currency exchange rates. The value of an investment and any income from it may fall as well as rise and investors may get back less than they invested. The historic yield reflects distributions declared over the past twelve months as a percentage of the Trust’s price, as at the date shown. It does not include any preliminary charge and investors may be subject to tax on their distributions. Tax legislation and the levels of relief from taxation can change at any time. Any change in the tax status of a Trust or in tax legislation could affect the value of the investments held by the Trust or its ability to provide returns to its investors. The yield is not guaranteed and will fluctuate. There is no guarantee that the objective of the investments will be met. Shares in an Investment Trust are listed on the London Stock Exchange and their price is affected by supply and demand. This means that the share price may be different from the NAV.
Neither the views nor the information contained within this document constitute investment advice or an offer to invest or to provide discretionary investment management services and should not be used as the basis of any investment decision. Any decision to invest should be based on information contained within the Prospectus, Investor disclosure document the relevant key information document and the latest report and accounts. The investment policy and process of the Trust(s) may not be suitable for all investors. If you are in doubt about whether the Trust(s) is/are suitable for you, please contact a professional adviser. References to specific securities are included for the purposes of illustration only and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities. Although Troy Asset Management Limited considers the information included in this document to be reliable, no warranty is given as to its accuracy or completeness. The opinions expressed are expressed at the date of this document and, whilst the opinions stated are honestly held, they are not guarantees and should not be relied upon and may be subject to change without notice. Third party data is provided without warranty or liability and may belong to a third party. Ratings from independent rating agencies should not be taken as a recommendation.
Please note that the Personal Asset Trust is registered for distribution to the public in the UK and to Professional investors only in Ireland.
All reference to FTSE indices or data used in this paper is © FTSE International Limited (“FTSE”) 2023. ‘FTSE ®’ is a trademark of the London Stock Exchange Group companies and is used by FTSE under licence.
Issued by Troy Asset Management Limited, 33 Davies Street, London W1K 4BP (registered in England & Wales No. 3930846). Registered office: Hill House, 1 Little New Street, London EC4A 3TR. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN: 195764) and registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) as an Investment Adviser (CRD: 319174). Registration with the SEC does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The product described in this document is neither available nor offered in the USA or to U.S. Persons.
Copyright © Troy Asset Management Ltd 2023

Welcome to the Personal Assets Trust website

This terms of use (together with the documents referred to in it) tells you the terms of use on which you may make use of our website https://www.patplc.co.uk (“our site”).  Use of our site includes accessing and browsing on our site.

Please read these terms of use carefully before you start to use our site, as these will apply to your use of our site.  By accessing and continuing to use our site, you are deemed to have read, understood,  and accepted these terms of use and to have agreed to comply with them.


These terms are to be read by you together with any other terms, conditions or disclaimers provided in the pages of our site. These terms incorporate the following additional terms, which also apply to your use of our site:

  • Our Privacy Policy (https://www.patplc.co.uk/privacy-policy/), which sets out the way in which we process personal data about you, including that we collect from you, that you provide to us or that we generate. By using our site, you acknowledge and agree to such processing and you warrant that all data provided by you is accurate. Use of your personal information submitted via our site is governed by our Privacy Policy.
  • Our Cookies Policy (https://www.patplc.co.uk/cookies/), which sets out details of the cookies used on our site and the way in which we use log files and tracking technologies.

If you do not agree to these terms of use, you must not use our site.


https://www.patplc.co.uk is a site operated by Personal Assets Trust Public Limited Company (“Personal Assets Trust” or “We”).  Personal Assets Trust is registered in Scotland under company number SC074582 and our registered office is at 28 Walker Street, Edinburgh EH3 7HR. Personal Assets Trust is an Investment Company within the meaning of Section 833 of the Companies Act 2006.

If you have any questions about these terms of use, please contact us in writing and address this to the Company at c/o Juniper Partners Limited, 28 Walker Street, Edinburgh EH3 7HR.


We may revise or replace these terms of use at any time (without notice to you) by amending this page.

Please check these terms each time you use our site to ensure that you understand the terms that apply at that time. By continuing to use and access our site following such changes, you agree to be bound by any variation made by us. It is your responsibility to check these terms from time to time so as to be aware of any such variations. This version was last updated in February 2023.


We may update our site from time to time, and may change, remove or replace the content and information at any time. However, please note that any of the content or information on our site may be out of date at any given time, and we are under no obligation to update it.

We do not guarantee that our site, or any content or information on it, will be free from errors or omissions.


Your access to and use of our site (for which we shall not be liable) is at your own initiative and risk, and you are solely responsible for your use of our site, the use to which you put information contained on it and any decisions you make regarding any investments. It shall be your own responsibility to ensure that any products, services or information available through our site meet your specific requirements.


We try to make sure that our site is accurate, up-to-date and free from bugs, but we cannot promise that it will be. Furthermore, we do not guarantee that our site will be fit or suitable for any purpose. Any reliance that you may place on the information on our site is at your own risk.

We do not guarantee that our site, or any content on it, will always be available or be uninterrupted. Access to our site is permitted on a temporary basis.

We may suspend, withdraw, discontinue or change the availability of all or any part of our site without notice at any time that we see fit. We will not be liable to you if for any reason our site is unavailable at any time or for any period.

You are responsible for making all arrangements necessary for you to have access to our site.

You are also responsible for ensuring that all persons who access our site through your internet connection are aware of these terms of use and other applicable terms and conditions, and that they comply with them.

We try to make our site as accessible as possible. If you have any difficulties using our site, please contact us using the contact details in the ‘Information About Us’ section above.


We are the owner or the licensee of all intellectual property rights including without limitation copyright and related rights, trade marks, domain names, database rights, and any and all other intellectual property rights of any kind whether registered or unregistered anywhere in the world in our site, and in any text, images, video, audio or other content, software or other information or material submitted to, contained on or accessible from our site (“Works”).  The Works are protected by copyright laws and treaties around the world and all other applicable intellectual property laws.  All such rights are reserved. This means that we or our licensors (as applicable) remain the owner of them and are free to use them as they see fit.

Certain words, phrases, names, designs, icons, graphics or logos used on our site may constitute trade marks, service marks or trade names of Personal Assets Trust or other entities. The display of any trade marks on our site does not imply that a licence has been granted for any further use by you. Any unauthorised downloading, re-transmission or other copying or modification of trade marks that occurs without our prior written consent is strictly prohibited and may be a violation of statutory or common law and/or trade mark law and could be subject to legal action.

You may view, print off one copy, and may download extracts, of any page(s) from our site for your own personal non-commercial use and you may draw the attention of others within your organisation to content posted on our site. Any other use of the Works is prohibited unless you have received an appropriate licence for that use from us or our licensors. You may not use or export or re-export the Works in violation of applicable laws. Nothing in these terms, or on our site, grants you any rights in our site or the Works other than as necessary for you to use our site in accordance with these terms.

You must not modify the paper or digital copies of any materials you have printed off or downloaded in any way, and you must not use any illustrations, photographs, video or audio sequences or any graphics separately from any accompanying text.

Our status (and that of any identified contributors) as the authors of the Works must always be acknowledged.

You must not use any part of the Works for commercial purposes without obtaining a licence to do so from us or our licensors.

If you print off, copy or download any part of our site in breach of these terms of use, your right to use our site will cease immediately and you must, at our option, return or destroy any copies of the materials you have made.


While we try to make sure that our site is secure, we do not actively monitor or check whether information supplied to us through our site is confidential, commercially sensitive or valuable.

Any unencrypted or otherwise unprotected e-mail communication over the internet is, as with communication via any other medium, not confidential, subject to possible interception or loss, and is also subject to possible alteration. We are not responsible for and will not be liable to you or anyone else for any damages in connection with an e-mail sent by you to us or an e-mail sent by us to you at your request. We cannot accept any responsibility for unauthorised access by a third party or the corruption of data sent to it.

Other than any personal information which will be dealt with in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy, we do not guarantee that information supplied to us through our site will be kept confidential and we may use it on an unrestricted and free-of-charge basis as we reasonably see fit.


The content on our site is provided for general information purposes only.  It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely and nothing on our site is intended to constitute an invitation or inducement to engage in investment activity in any jurisdiction. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. For the avoidance of doubt, any investment decisions relating to Personal Assets Trust should be made on the basis of the final terms of such investment/opportunity and not on the basis of the content on our site. Should you undertake any investment activity based on the content on our site, you do so entirely at your own risk and Personal Assets Trust shall have no liability whatsoever for any loss, damage, costs or expenses incurred or suffered by you as a result.

Whilst prepared in good faith, the content on our site does not purport to be comprehensive nor has it been verified. Personal Assets Trust and its affiliates, partners, associated businesses, licensors and their respective officers, directors, employees and agents disclaim all representation or warranty as to the accuracy, completeness, currency, correctness, reliability, integrity, quality, fitness for purpose or originality of any Information and, to the fullest extent permitted by law, all implied warranties, conditions or other terms of any kind are hereby excluded. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of you or anyone else using our site or relying on any of the content on our site.

Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Market and currency movements may cause the value of investments and the income and other returns from them to go down as well as up and you may get back less than you invested.


Nothing in these terms of use excludes or limits our liability for death or personal injury arising from our negligence, or our fraud or fraudulent misrepresentation, or any other liability that cannot be excluded or limited by law.

To the extent permitted by law, we exclude all conditions, warranties, representations or other terms which may apply to our site or any content on it, whether express or implied.

We will not be liable to any user for any loss or damage, whether in contract, tort (including negligence), breach of statutory duty, or otherwise, even if foreseeable, arising under or in connection with:

  • use of, or inability to use, our site; or
  • use of or reliance on any content displayed on our site.

We will not be liable for any loss arising as a result of a cause which is beyond our control, including failure of electronic or mechanical equipment of any kind, failure of communication systems (including telephone, cable or internet), unauthorised access, theft, operator error or any similar event.

If you are a business user, we will not be liable for:

  • loss of profits, sales, business, contracts, income or revenue;
  • loss of data;
  • business interruption;
  • loss of anticipated savings;
  • loss of business opportunity, goodwill or reputation; or
  • any indirect or consequential loss or damage.


If you are a consumer, you may only access our site for domestic and private use. You agree not to use our site for any commercial or business purposes.


As a condition of your use of our site, you agree not to attempt to gain unauthorised access to our site, the server on which our site is stored or any server, computer or database connected to our site.

We may prevent or suspend your access to our site if you do not comply with anything contained in these terms or any applicable law.


We do not guarantee that our site will be secure or free from bugs or viruses.  You are responsible for configuring your information technology and computer programmes in order to access our site and you should use your own virus protection software when accessing our site.

You must not misuse our site by knowingly introducing viruses, trojans, worms, logic bombs or other material which is malicious or technologically harmful.  You must not attempt to gain unauthorised access to our site, the server on which our site is stored or any server, computer or database connected to our site.  You must not attack our site via a denial-of-service attack or a distributed denial-of service attack.  By breaching this provision, you would commit a criminal offence under the Computer Misuse Act 1990.  We will report any such breach to the relevant law enforcement authorities and we will co-operate with those authorities by disclosing your identity to them.  In the event of such a breach, your right to use our site will cease immediately.


You may link to our home page, provided you do so in a way that is fair and legal and does not damage our reputation or take advantage of it and the website you link from does not contain any content that is unlawful, threatening, abusive, libellous, pornographic, obscene, vulgar, indecent, offensive or which infringes on the intellectual property rights or other rights of any third party.

You must not establish a link in such a way as to suggest any form of association, approval or endorsement on our part where none exists.

Our site must not be framed on any other site, nor may you create a link to any part of our site other than the home page.

We reserve the right to withdraw linking permission without notice.


Where our site contains links to other sites and resources provided by third parties, these links are provided for your information only. We have no control over the contents of those sites or resources and are not responsible for the content of these sites or for anything provided by them. We do not guarantee that these sites or resources will be continuously available. The fact that we include links to such external sites does not imply any endorsement of, or association with, their operators. We will not be liable for any loss or damage that may arise from your use of any such links. Please note that your use of a third party website may be governed by the terms and conditions of that third party website.


These terms of use, its subject matter and its formation, are governed by Scottish law provided that, if you are a consumer and resident elsewhere, you will retain the benefit of any mandatory protections given to you by the law of that country.

If you are a business, you hereby submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of Scotland to finally adjudicate or determine any suit, action or proceeding arising in connection with any disputes, controversies or claims arising out of or in connection with our site (Dispute If you are a consumer, you agree to submit to the non-exclusive jurisdiction of the Scottish courts in respect of any Dispute provided that nothing in these terms shall prevent a consumer from taking proceedings in respect of a Dispute in any other courts with jurisdiction.

Nothing shall prevent us from bringing proceedings to protect our intellectual property rights before any competent court.


To contact us, please click here.

I accept this disclaimer

Newsletter Signup

By sending us this request you are confirming that you would like to receive investment updates from us.

Our privacy notice provides you with information about how we gather and use personal information.

If at any time you decide that you no longer wish to receive investment updates from us, please contact us at [email protected] or on +44(0)20 7499 4030.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Join Mailing List

To be sent more information on the Trust, please register using the link below.

Register interest